The recipe I share below is our favorite, but Ill share all kinds of variations so you can make these exactly how your family likes. Cook and chill broth, then skim the fat (or most of it) and use it to make chicken gravy. Home | Recipes | Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwiches. When I need to de-stress, I head into the kitchen to bake. Thanks for indulging him with this regional fave. Just got back from a trip to Findlay (first time in 20 years) specifically to visit relatives AND the county fair. Oh I hope you find some Ballreichs! I remember having these sandwiches in the school cafeteria. Cant wait to hear what you think of my variation (no pressure! This was so good, thank you! The recipe says cook chicken in crockpot then add ingredients..what do you put in with the chicken to cook it? Shred the chicken with two forks, your fingers, or (for max ease) use a hand mixer and shred it right in the crock pot. area of NE Ohio .. Stark .. Holmes .. Tuscarawas Counties. I remember they used to serve these occasionally at school for lunch. Try it! Please refer to our disclosure policy for more information. Originally from Clyde, Ohio in Sandusky County. Toast the hoagie rolls in a 450 degree oven for a few minutes, and then scoop on the chicken and top with . If you managed to have the ladies who made their own noodles with fresh farm eggs, well, your reception got rave reviews. Creating recipes in her kitchen is how she relaxes. What temperature should I put my crockpot at?? Its not on a menu anywhere that Ive seen, and Ive lived in this area for a good 35 years. (-) Information is not currently available for this nutrient. Noodles and mashed potatoes. Then the next year they say, I hope you made those noodles. Ohio lives on in so many memories and the food we eat. The internet and I find someone from home.Imagine.. I may need to give it a try too. I really havent found them in other parts of the state. When I left Ohio for the military I was shocked and disheartened to learn these sandwiches were regional to Ohio. Who would have guessed!? I love shredded chicken recipes. Who Dey. My sisters and I have made them too! And honestly, you will find the same when cooking from fresh. Now thats a new one. We used Keystone in Lima for our chicken and always had brought some home whenever I visited. Thanks! Really is a Pennsylvania Dutch tradition. When you visit the site, Dotdash Meredith and its partners may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. Pour Sauce over the chicken. The best method is using a stand-mixer. I like it that way. Add Cream of Chicken or Mushroom soup (I have used both) and thicken more with little cornstarch\broth mixture to thicken to your own taste. Use canned chicken. Thanks for the new treat for me to serve. Lisa- Thanks for that question. I grew up on these! Cook on medium for approx 2 hours or until warmed thru, stir as needed. Im originally from LIma, Ohio and loved these so much. In a medium bowl, mix all together. I want to triple this recipe for a gathering and already have chicken cut up to use. For those who've never heard nor seen one of these .. imagine a "sloppy joe" with shredded chicken and butter sauce instead of ground beef and tomato sauce. Andrew, thanks so much for sharing your story with this recipe! Usually about a sleeve from the box of Ritz will do it, sometimes more - sometimes less. Total Time 30 Minutes Serving Size 6 Servings Ingredients Directions Recipe Nutrition Information - Per Serving Made With TAGS American Main Dish Sandwiches 300 Calories or Less Chicken You will need cooked, shredded chicken. Pick the chicken (let it cool a bit so you dont burn your hands) being careful to remove all bones and skin. Now Im a Hoosier and my sister-in-law tried was experimenting with the recipe and used Stove Top stuffing instead of crackers. I grew up in Sidney! They are the BEST!!! Instant Pot- cook for 8 minutes with a quick pressure release. Im going to have to pick some up. Sounds like an easy go-to sandwich idea. I should have read the recipe before adding everything. It was always the FAVORITE school cafeteria lunchno one packed on chicken sandwich day. Just water or broth? I live in the Toledo areaMy absolute favorite sandwich!!! Perfect! It give a small leafy/earthy undertone. Shredded Hot Chicken Sandwiches. It really made my day! thanks. in Education and over 30 years of cooking and baking, I want to teach YOU the best of our family recipes. I have been looking for this exact recipe for some time. One bird is just as tasty as the next. Must be a Findlay thing , This regional fave even has regional differences. So, i boiled the chicken meat and shredded it like directed but instead of simmering in the pot. I just couldnt throw it away! Serve these on toasted buns with mayo, cheese, lettuce, and tomato for the ultimate lunch! I live in southern Ohio and shredded chicken never made it here so Im really happy to have a recipe so I can eat it more than once every few years. Sue D., Summertown, Tennessee. They just completed their 58th season! Add the shredded chicken back to the slow cooker along with the parmesan cheese. Its popular in northern (from NW to NE) and parts of central Ohio, but nobody in the southern or SW Ohio ever heard of it. That is now his favorite shredded chicken sandwich. Strain the broth through a fine mesh strainer. Also makes a great open face sandwich, add your favorite toppings, enjoy. Ive always been a huge fan of shredded chicken. I just thought it was curious that a school system would regularly make shredded chicken sandwiches available to their students. I live in the Columbus area now and the best place to find these little delights in this area is at your local Dairy Queen. Let it cook down for about 30 minute and you have enough for about 50 sandwiches. Transfer dough to pizza pan. (Kind of like putting katchup on eggs!) I LOVE stained recipe cards- the sign of a well-loved favorite! All rights reserved. White Oak Grove Sandwiches) also no chips or crackers, but one of the best and sloppiest sandwiches ever! Easy Rotisserie Pulled Chicken Sandwich - Kinders . Oven- bake at 425 in a covered baking dish for 25-30 minutes, until the chicken reaches an internal temperature of 165F. From trendy favorites like Chicken & Waffles to traditional classics like Lemon Roasted Chicken, you'll find plenty to love when you try our family-tested and tummy-approved Amish recipes that feature the first chicken that . All rights reserved. Im from Mansfield, too and everyone I know that makes these sandwiches says no to the crackers or chips. I think this recipe will help to make this party a hit!! Store any leftovers in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. Omit the stuffing and crackers and just enjoy the chicken, soup, and seasonings. I think one of the reasons why this recipe became such a mainstay in Ohio kitchens is because its very budget friendly AND its ready to go in 10 15 minutes if you use chicken that has already been cooked. Thanks for sharing! Rebecca- great question! Before downloading Amish Shredded Chicken Sandwiches Videos, The world largest online music service. I'm Julie Clark, CEO and recipe developer of Tastes of Lizzy T. With my B.A. Yummy. What To Serve With Pork Chops 31 Recipes. So good. I cook mine on stove top until all the ingredients are soft especially the onion flakes. The men always took two, chicken sandwiches and went back for more. Chicken combined with creamy soup and crushed crackers or potato chips come together to make one tasty sandwich. Cover and cook on low for 3-4 hours or high for 2-3 hours, until chicken is cooked through (165 degrees F minimum) and fall apart tender. And if you try a new filler ingredient- let us know which one. We arr actually on our way to Tiffin, Ohio right now for a small family reunion and planning to stock up on a supply of Ballreights , Ive lived on the lake 30 miles west of Cleveland in Amherst my whole 63 yrs and never heard of this. This hot and creamy chicken sandwich is so easy to make, only requires a handful of ingredients, and is budget friendly. Tried it tonight and loved it! or the original Route 30 by Central Catholic HS? Great ways to customize the recipe for your taste. The seasoning packet adds some additional flavor. Slather it on toasted whole-grain bread, then layer with grilled chicken, escarole, and sharp cheddar. Thank you for posting this. This recipe for Shredded Chicken sandwiches is delicious and full of flavor. Leftovers mixed with cooked noodles make a great casserole. Live in Southern California now. I cannot wait to try these recipes! They are simply delicious! Im originally from Nee Phila!!! Combine the chicken, mayonnaise and herbs in a bowl. Is it tasty? If needed, use a good quality chicken stock to make gravy. Ive never tried making this with chips or crackers or croutons. Lots of recipes but they nearly all the same. GRANDMA'S CHICKEN SALAD: Amish Country chef, Lee Ann Miller, offers up an amazing recipe for a homemade chicken salad. Stir soup and water into the pot. I would love going places with concession stands because you knew thered be shredded chicken sandwiches. I would imagine you could though. Im making a note to research that idea! Recently discovered this recipe and dont know how Ive lived without it! No one ever knows what Im talking about when I say I miss these yummy sandwiches!! (Im 66.) 0.00 Mitt(s) 0 Rating(s) Prep: 15 mins. If you would like to use this method, add chicken to the slow cooker and 1 can of cream of chicken soup. I usually make this for my family and we get at least two meals out of it. (to thin only if the mixture seems to thick), The calories shown are based on the recipe serving 10, with 1 serving being 1/10 of the chicken (no bun). At our 4-H fair, the homemakers club had a booth and sold these sandwiches! With 3 kids I know it can be hard getting food on the table. My aunts used the whole chicken if they couldnt get their hands on the canned chicken. Let me know how they turn out. These where the staple at them with a bowl of homemade ice cream. And its sooo easy! Jones Potato Chip factory. They havent disowned me. Step 2: Add in the remaining ingredients. I hope you enjoy my trip down memory lane .. even if you haven't ever tried this dish! " Instructions. Im in Clark county Ohio. I tried recreating them many times, years ago to no avail. Deanna- yes it does freeze well! I live in North Carolina now. Cook: Cover and cook for 1 hour on high or 2-3 hours on low. My dad is from Bellvillepart of the Snyder family. Judy Ault Billings. This traditional Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich Recipe is a classic. I hope I can make the same as what Ohio offers. Place chicken breasts into crock pot. Open stuffing and can of cream of chicken, mix with large spoon or use clean hands to break up meat and throughly mix ingredients. In Bremen the Fire Dept. For some reason it just makes me smile every time someone mentions eating this at a DQ! And Im really intrigued with the baked chicken and gravy. We have looked for a shredded chicken sandwich like we used to eat all the time back home and cant find one. Return 4 cups of the strained broth to the pot and return to a boil. Add all ingredients to the slow cooker. This is what Im making for Fathers Day, have it available in the Crock Pot for self-serve. I live in Wyoming now and cant find them anywhere! Im definitely going to try that the next time I make it! I was looking for a recipe that mimicked the hot shredded chicken sandwiches that Maxs drive in North Canton served. Will try making it with rotisserie chicken. I am a IL transplant from NW Ohio, Defiance Co. No one makes pulled chicken sandwiches around here! INN THE PINES made theirs with baked chicken and gravy, mashed potatoes on the side, and freshly-made hot waffles with homemade ice cream for dessert (ever had a waffle ice-cream sandwich??) Thanks so much for the detailed comment. Quick question, do I add the canned soup AND the broth to make the shredded chicken, or just the can of condensed soup no mixer? Let them cool completely before shredding them by hand or with a fork. I lived in Tiffin until my family moved when I was in the 6th Grade. Season with salt and pepper to taste. Lots of you mentioned using canned chicken for the base (specifically this one) but I dont think hubs will let me try that variation. My mom taught me to make it with potato flakes though, as a thickener, but a lot of people I know used crackers. My Grandmother Grace made tons of these for the county fair for years to support Howard Methodist Church in Findlay, Ohio. Thats how I was taught to make it. This recipe is the closest to the one that my mom has made for years. Just thought Id ask Im hoping this is the recipe that I remember from Friday night football games and chinese auctions (are these an ohio thing too)? shredded chicken in my freezer and would like to use it for this but am not sure how much to use. Thanks so much for sharing, I really do love reading all these personal stories! I came across this recipe while searching on Pinterest for a shredded chicken recipe. I really like it that you included side dish suggestions. Yum! Finish cooking as directed above. I even know people who use dried stuffing mix. erin my grandma carol was from toledo ohio. Lived here most of my life. Up in Wapakoneta, Auglaize County, OH. The only thing that made it tolerable was knowing Id get a shredded chicken sandwich from the concession trailer at lunch time. The crackers are there to dry up the sandwich. I just started using the mixer hack to shred the chicken- game changer! Separate the egg yolk and white, and reserve the egg white in a small bowl. Hot, creamy, shredded chicken piled on a soft hamburger bun. I love the drink pairing, root beer float- Perfect! I have relatives from GH IM FROM Vaughnsville in Putnam Co. left after college in 1962, but the chicken sandwiches served at church suppers are one of my best memories. Shred the chicken, then add the stuffing mix. Oh wow, do you know where? There were loads of innovations at our drive-ins .. Fast "Fried Chicken" before Colonel Sanders ever ventured north. Spent my childhood in the 60s-70s being dragged around to auctions by my mom. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Moved to Houston in 1995. The home and visiting teams loved them. Looking forward to giving this recipe a try. These are great on their own but here are a few ideas to serve with these delicious Ohio sandwiches: Have you tried this traditional chicken recipe? Cheesy Zucchini & Summer Squash Casserole, Sriracha Shrimp with Tomato Cucumber Gazpacho, Spaghetti aux Crevettes et Tomate Crmeuse. Cook on high for 3 hours and then shred the chicken. Another mentioned its church potluck history easy to serve a crowd. Remove liquid from Instant Pot and then add chicken back in. You can add bread crumbs or Ritz crackers to thicken if too runny or make more gravy if too stiff. Place chicken and sauce in skillet over low heat until warm. Yep. Ask for one outside of Ohio and you get an open face chicken sandwich with gravy on top!! Want to add a little more flavor, try substituting crackers with sour cream and onion potato chips. I worked in Bowling Green and my favorite lunch was DQ chicken sandwich & rootbeer float. . I bet it has more flavor! Web Step 3. Hope that helps. How to Make Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwiches Place the chicken breasts in the slow cooker. Does the mixture freeze well as leftovers or if made ahead of time? Thanks for the memories, everyone. There was a meal at the church afterward with so much delicious food, including a big pile of buns and a big dish of the chicken mix. We always used Brinkmans canned turkey or chicken for our Hot Chicken sandwiches. I was at a loss of what to make. Im going to have to order some Jones chips and have them shipped. Spoon onto buns and serve. I was born and raised in Fremont, Ohio. They can be incorporated in other dishes or in salads. Here you will find easy and delicious recipes that the whole family will enjoy. We used Stove Top stuffing mix with cream of chicken, and the broth from roasting the turkey. Cooking them down this way would allow a farmer to get one last use of the chicken and enjoy a meal. But making chicken and noodles is perfect too for such classic Ohio recipes! To me its gross tasting and cant figure out why anyone would want to eat chicken filled with bread on a bun. I just use leftover chicken-or turkey from Thanksgiving leftovers). Pour the condensed soup overtop. Heat a cast iron skillet over medium heat and drizzle in the olive oil. Those are good but try potato sticks instead of chips. I am from Knox County Ohio. And no not from Ohio, I love the Thanksgiving twist on yours. Cream of chicken soup You can substitute with cream of mushroom or cream of celery if you prefer. Lima also is the home of the Kewpee restaurant. All that comfort food gave me something to focus on instead of crying. Shredded chicken can be made in a variety of ways. Do you know if it will still turn out ok! Then you could use milk and limited other ingredients which were all available to farmers thus the Ohio roots of these sandwiches. During this COVID time, I was looking for a little comfort food. We have two DQs in our immediate area and neither one offers this sandwich. I grew up in North Canton, now live in Wisconsin. Classic Ohio Sandwich, Hot Shredded Chicken Sandwich, Shredded Chicken Sandwich, Shredded Chicken Sandwich filling, Sloppy Chicken Sandwich. We may earn a commission when you make a purchase through links on our site. I have everything I need! Although I think my husband would revolt if I used canned meat (he say he can taste the difference) I also use any leftovers to make creamy chicken soup with it. The region now has a handful of airports taking international flights. Im going to try without when I make them. And deep fried- that one to try! Local Dairy Queen makes the best shredded chicken sandwich. Instructions. The best Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwiches! Was raised in Newark, OH. paprika Crackers or slider buns Serve with slider buns, crackers or pita chips Directions 1 Mix all ingredients together. So when you cook the chicken in a crockpot you dont need to add any liquid to it for the first couple of hours? If you are using leftover chicken, do this same process. I use everything except bones and skin. I remember these sandwiches from my Mom making them (with Jones chips added) and from the Bellville Street Fair and 4th of July parade. You want the texture to be solid, you need it to hold its shape in a hamburger bun but to give when you bite into it. How many will this serve. DQ is where I had my first shredded chicken sandwich. Do you have some leftovers from this classic meal? So many fond memories, one of which was stopping for these chicken sandwiches on the way there and back. Long ago when the kids were little, I used to make a creamy chicken & stuffing in the slow cooker. LOL, Grew up in St. Marys, Ohio. Drain most of the bacon grease and cook the onion and garlic in the rest. We have not seen any place in Florida that serves these sandwiches. But can you give me a volume (or weight) measurement for the shredded chicken, please? That would make sense with the limited ingredients in them as people had access to limited items. You can only use Ritz crackers and cream of chicken soup, you need a buttery cracker.I beleive my mom tried to sneak in some cream of Mushroom soup once and there was revolt and on my part revulsion (save that mushroom soup for green bean casserole! Thanks for sharing! And let me know if this version holds up! I never get tired of hearing the stories with this recipe! The "Shredded Chicken" sandwich has been a mainstay of poor people that stretched the protein by utilizing "picked" chicken carcasses and creating a substantial sandwich that is the heartbeat of anyone in the area over 40 years old. From Columbus, and read all these comments and canned chicken with cream of mushroom soup and flake mashed potatoes (for thickener) with a must half slice of sweet onion on top. I also cook chickens at least one day in advance, refrigerate, then skim hardened fat off top. Tired of barbecue. Thanks for the reminiscing! Thanks Mary! but hed say no. . Ive only found these sandwiches in Ohio (Dairy Queen, baby showers, sporting events) & miss them so much. Thank you for sharing those tips and suggestions! I have had sandwiches with shredded chicken before, but I have never used this recipe. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We moved from Piqua, Ohio 3-1/2 years ago to Florida. Directions Place all of the chicken into the pot of your pressure cooker or slow cooker. That sounds like a great idea to add to the buns!! Step 1: In a medium-sized pan, add in your chicken and take two forks and shred the chunks of chicken. Cover and cook on LOW for 4 hours. They are served at all family gatherings and community events. Great tip! I grew up in Sidney, OH. There are a million versions of the recipe, and all of the above are good. Add cup or so of broth, salt and pepper and simmer until chicken is really tender. Ballreichs are the best. If you are from Ohio, you might be familiar with these shredded chicken sandwiches. Cook on medium about 3 to 5 minutes, stirring periodically until heated throughout. Cover and cook on low for 3-4 hours or until the chicken is shreddable. Guess where Im going for lunch today! They grew up in St. Marys, they are both now deceased and buried there. I will be one happy lady tonight when I eat these for after all of these years. Set aside. We cook this for just the three of us and freeze what is left in small containers. Susan sorry to hear you didnt care for my version of this nostalgic recipe. I grew up in Northwest Ohio on Roots shredded chicken sandwiches and have missed them greatly since moving down south. But each crockpot will cook a little different, so just watch it. I sure do miss home. Hello Mary, Oh my gosh, I remember eating these sandwiches at my Grandmas. Now I have your recipe to try. Shred the chicken using two forks or kitchen tongs. Rule the Jungle! Add dried torn bread to a large bowl. I added all the breaded ingredients to my chicken and soup before cooking! Wait. ? 1 (3 pound) chicken - cooked, deboned and shredded, 2 (10.75 ounce) cans condensed cream of mushroom soup, (16 ounce) package buttery round crackers, crushed. 6 / 37. This hot, creamy chicken sandwich recipe is from my sister. Make it all the time for potlucks for my new school and they love it. Thanks for stopping by to share your story with this recipe! My son is raising his family in MO, and he ALWAYS makes chicken sandwiches for his wife and kids when they start feeling better. If you feel that its a little too dry, add in a 1/4 cup of chicken broth or water. I would actually just recommend leaving out the chips. Notes To me all you taste is stuffing. Afterward I deboned, de-tendoned, and deskinned the the bird and put all that mess back into the pressure-cooker and covered it with the stock it was cooked in previously. Copyright 2022 foodlovinfamily.com. Add 1 tsp crushed black pepper, salt to taste, 1 chicken stock cube (optional), 3 garlic cloves roughly crushed, a small piece of ginger crushed, 1 bay leaf, and chicken breast. My boss makes this sometimes for our birthday carry in lunches. The Kewpee was, and still is, famous for: square hamburgers, frosted chocolate malted, and chili but no fries for many years. Maxies is gone so now the spot is Woodys for their shredded chicken sandwich. (or you could just make this recipe! Step 4: Spoon onto the buns. My father-in-law, who was a meat and potatos guy, always liked when I fixed this for football Saturdays, or any night for quick and easy meals. Shredded chicken sandwiches are a leftover from the days when everyone had chickens and you didn't butcher them until they quit laying eggs. Thanks. The mixture will still taste delicious and cook up fine. Was looking for something different to do with chicken because its just the 2 of us now trying not to make huge dinners and go with sandwiches and soups. My sister, who lives in Ohio, often makes the pulled chicken for family gatherings. p.s. You would definitely get a delicious flavor profile since you are using the thigh meat. are we related???? Let us know how it turns out. I literally grew up in restaurants .. back in the day, my father started a "mini-chain" of 3 drive-in chicken and burger joints called "Farmlad". Throw some Conns potato chips on the plate with the sandwich and you got a group of happy ppl. Hi Rhonda Stir to mix with sauce. You will find the complete ingredients list as well as the full directions in the free printable recipe card below. Oh my! . Ive become a Mike-Sells girl. By that time they were so old and tough that all one could do was make creamed chicken and serve it in buns or over biscuits. WOW! Im making these for an office beach day and thinking of offering a variety of sandwich toppings. I make this alot for family or group so simple . Shred with fork or chop into small pieces. Learning to do it from scratch is insurance that Ill never lose my favorite chicken sandwich. Perfect for large gatherings and easy weeknight meal prep thanks to the crockpot! Loved these too! (At home, we used Keystone, Sweet Sue, or Brinkmans from Findlay). My daughters favorite meal!! Now thats a Buckeye sandwich! And have a great party! Ha. The chips mentioned in the comments dont taste the same as they did when I was growing up in the area, but they were great chips. I Made It Print Nutrition Facts (per serving) Show Full Nutrition Label You'll Also Love BBQ Chicken Sandwiches Let the noodles set for 30 minutes, stirring every 10 minutes or so. You can add a bit more of lemon juice if you like along with little olive oil. Thank you. Pour in chicken broth and sprinkle with seasonings. What a great recipe. I didnt have poultry seasoning but the salt, pepper, garlic powder and chicken broth provided pretty good flavor by themselves. Wish me luck! , Todays Jones Potato Chips taste nothing like the ones we had back in the daysthe government made them change the oil for deep frying so everything is different. You can cook it in a can of cream of chicken soup or broth. Oh no it is very popular in southern Ohio. Sounds like a perfect plan for Fathers Day! Im making them today for a cookie bake off and a meal to drop off to friends. Looks super. These shredded chicken sandwiches are served warm on hamburger buns.